Dear "The Duke", What the heck are you doing, buddy?

By -
While reading through Measure for Measure, I find myself drawn to The Duke's "Undercover Boss" approach to things.

That's really what this play kind of is... a really trippy and shady episode of "Undercover Boss"... (Throwback to McKenna's wonderful post)

Even with that kind of explanation, I still have a hard time wrapping my mind around "Why?". I get it, you get bored, you decide to shake things up, but there's too much here to just chop it up to that. The Duke was too "soft" when it came to ruling and Lord Angelo being almost the exact opposite of that can't be a coincidence. Surely, The Duke could have seen that coming... at least a little bit.

So, again, why? Was he trying to learn to be a more merciless ruler by observing Angelo? Was he just hoping Angelo would take care of it all at once and leave The Duke with all the jobs done upon his return?

Poor Isabella, the timing of this must have been stressful.

The Duke's motivations are rather... unclear and it makes me think about the difference between complicated characters that are always one step ahead and characters that straight up are just a guessing game. I believe The Duke to be the latter. He's not pulling off some complicated scheme, he's just doing things to better his current situation; be it boredom, a learning experience, or taking advantage of a more merciless personality. Not to mention he really just pretended to be a friar, that's not exactly the definition of complicated undercover mission.

So when I say it can be hard to pinpoint his exact motivation, I think it's because the situation is all too simple and maybe The Duke wasn't really thinking at all. Maybe he was just like, "Well, let's see how this does," and rolled with it.

While manipulation is a part of his game, there could be a form of impulsiveness behind it, too. The Duke isn't a perfect character by a landslide but it was his decisions that had to actually start the plot so it feels like you can also answer "for plot reasons" when you ask "Why are you doing this?"

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Ghosts of Othello in Get Out

By -
*SPOILERS FOR THE FILM GET OUT * When I first saw Jordan Peele's directorial debut  Get Out , I never thought there was anything particularly Shakespearean about it. But thanks to this class--and my newfound ability to find Shakespeare references literally everywhere--I managed to somehow get more out of this amazing film than ever before. In particular, this film stuck out to me as almost a companion piece to discussion surrounding the play Othello . The race allegory is an obvious one. Photographer Chris Washington goes with his white girlfriend to meet her equally white family, and discomfort and micro-aggressions ensue from the first hello. We can make parallels between Chris and Othello: both are black (or at least POC) men who seem out of place in the white societies of their respective universes. Their skin color seems to be their defining trait to everyone around them, to the point that almost all conversations with or about their characters involve their blackness in s...
Read more

Where are the female writers?

By -
    Dr. Whitney Sperrazz a’s lecture on the ignored female writers under Shakespeare’s shadow was really inspiring, as it reminded me of the invisible female writers throughout Chinese history. At first, she asked us to name a few women writers in Shakespearean time, and I found it interesting that many of us didn’t have an answer. After the lecture, as I reflected on my literary education in the last 15 years, I found that I could also rarely name any female writers in Chinese history. The only names I knew was Cai Wenji who could write beautiful essays in late Han Dynasty, and another female poet, Qingzhao Li who lived in Song Dynasty. It was weird to have only two famous female writers in two thousand years of civilization. Also, like Shakespeare’s works, the works of important male writers in ancient China were also collected, sorted and revised over and over again, therefore having easier access than those female writers.     It is interesting to...
Read more